Acrylic vs Gel Nails: Which is Best for You? (2024)

Acrylic vs Gel Nails: Which is Best for You? (1)

Gel and acrylic nails are two of the most talked-about manicure options in the nail industry today. What’s the difference between the two, and how can you tell which is best for you and your lifestyle? Here’s a guide to help you decide between acrylic and gel nails for your next manicure!

Get the perfect at-home manicure in minutes with Smitten Tips gel nail polish strips! Made with real gel nail polish, our nail strips feature a semi-cure formulation for better fit and durability that lasts up to 14 days!

What are Acrylic Nails?

Acrylic vs Gel Nails: Which is Best for You? (2)

Acrylic nails are made of a combination of synthetic nail tips, powder (polymer), and a liquid (monomer) laid over the natural nail. First, a primer or glue is applied to the natural nail to help the synthetic nail tip and acrylic solution stick. A synthetic nail tip is applied to the natural nail, then the solution is placed over both and blended to make the entire nail look like one natural nail. Once the solution is applied, it can be molded into a variety of shapes and lengths.

After the solution is applied and set, the nails are painted with nail polish and typically an acrylic-friendly top coat. Then, the nails are placed under a fan to dry.

Acrylic nails are fairly affordable, with the average set running between $30 and $50. They’re also very durable and hard, and they can last for a long time if taken care of properly. One of the biggest benefits of acrylic nails is that they can easily be refilled for $20 or so.

Cons of Acrylic Nails

Acrylic nails tend to look much less natural than gel nails or plain natural nails. One of the biggest drawbacks is that since acrylic nails are so thick and inflexible, they can actually hurt the wearer’s cuticle and nail bed if too much pressure is applied. Additionally, acrylic nail application can damage the natural nails, since the nail surface needs to be filed and roughed up for the acrylic to stick. Acrylic nail application often involves using harsh, pungent chemicals, and the removal process can be tedious as well.

Getting the Best Results with Acrylic Nails

It’s important that acrylic nail wearers let their nails breathe in-between wears. If not, the natural nails might become unhealthy, and the risk of potential infection increases. Acrylic nails are ideal for those who already have strong and well-kept nails. They’re much more likely to crack or break if applied on top of natural nails that are weak or brittle.

What are Gel Nails?

Acrylic vs Gel Nails: Which is Best for You? (3)

Gel nails have a glossier appearance than typical acrylic nails. The nails are created using a pre-mixed powder and liquid solution. The gel can either be applied to natural nails or blended with synthetic tips. Typically, the process involves applying a base coat, two or three layers of gel nail polish coat, and a gel-friendly top coat. Each coat is cured under an LED or UV light for between thirty seconds and two minutes. Once all the layers are applied and cured, the gel nail application process is complete.

Note: There are some gel polishes that don’t require curing with light. These polishes usually cure and dry with either a gel activator or just a fan.

Benefits of Gel Nails

One of the biggest benefits of gel nails is their lasting power. Although gel nails are fairly flexible, they’re very durable and can last up to two weeks with proper care. Since gel nails are so flexible, there’s little risk of them injuring or damaging the wearer’s cuticles or nail beds.

Another major benefit is that gel nails tend to look very natural and can sometimes actually pass for natural nails. Additionally, gel nails can typically be removed simply by filing, and no harsh chemicals are needed.

Cons of Gel Nails

Gel nails can’t be filled in like acrylic nails, and a new set must be applied every time. That means more cost over time, which is why some prefer other nail application methods. Even so, the salon-finish look of gel nails is definitely worth it!

Getting the Best Results with Gel Nails

Gel nails typically last longer and cause less damage to the nail bed when applied with a non-acid base or primer. It’s also important to minimize gel nails’ exposure to water, as water can cause the nail polish to chip or break.

Should I Choose Acrylic or Gel Nails?

Choosing between acrylic and gel nails all depends on your budget, your lifestyle, and your preferences:

  • If your nails are already strong and you don’t do a lot of work with your hands, acrylic nails might be best for you.
  • If your natural nails are a little weak or if you need to be able to use your hands a lot on a day-to-day basis, gel nails might be the better option.
  • If you don’t want to have to do heavy buffing and filing, gel nails are the better option.
  • If you like a glossier finish, you’ll prefer gel nails over acrylic nails.

Try Smitten Tips Semi-cured Gel!

Acrylic vs Gel Nails: Which is Best for You? (4)

Smitten Tips semi-cured gel make it easy to get the perfect at-home manicure in minutes. Hand-painted and made with real nail polish, our nail strips feature a semi-cure formulation for better fit and durability that lasts up to 14 days!

Key Features

  • Semi-Cured. Our semi-cured formulation provides superior durability and a better fit. Get the salon look without all the chemicals.
  • Length? Yes! Our nail strips are designed to beautifully elongate your hands.
  • Small Batch. Small batch production ensures the highest level of quality.
  • Size Options. Our products come with 12 size options so you can get the best fit every time.
  • Multiple Applications. Each set comes with 30 strips for up to 2 applications.
  • Mirror Salon Finish. Get a professional nail salon look from your own home, in minutes!
  • Exclusive Designs. Stand out in style with our exclusive, limited-edition collections.
Acrylic vs Gel Nails: Which is Best for You? (2024)

FAQs

Acrylic vs Gel Nails: Which is Best for You? ›

However, if you crave a more natural look and prioritize nail health, then a gel manicure might be better. Gel polish offers a high-shine finish and may be less damaging, but it can sometimes chip more easily than acrylics. Consider your lifestyle and nail goals to make the best pick. Ultimately, you can try them both.

What is healthier gel or acrylic nails? ›

Acrylics tend to be more damaging because they're hard and inflexible, which makes them more likely to catch on surfaces and chip or break. Additionally, acrylic nails are more difficult to remove than gel nails, which means that they may be more likely to damage the natural nails.

What is the healthiest nail option? ›

Choose soak-off gel nails instead of acrylic nails.

This means your own nails are less likely to crack. You'll want to ask for gel nails that soak off rather than ones that must be filed off.

Do acrylic nails need UV light? ›

Acrylics start to cure when they come into contact with air, and usually completely dry in about 10-15 minutes. A UV light is not needed for acrylics, and is actually not recommended — it doesn't speed up the curing process like it does for gel nails.

What kind of fake nails are best? ›

Acrylic nails are definitely the most popular type of fake nails used today. Acrylic nails are made from a liquid and a powder that combine to form a hard protective layer over your natural nails. They are strong, durable, and can be shaped into any style you want.

Why do people prefer acrylic over gel? ›

They're also more flexible than acrylic nails, so if you have weak or brittle nails, gel is a good choice. However, gel nails can be more expensive than acrylics, and they require special UV light to cure. Acrylic nails are a more affordable option, and they're great if you want a durable nail that won't chip easily.

Which damages nails more acrylic or gel? ›

Gel nails are less likely to cause damage to natural nails than acrylic nails. They are less harsh on the natural nails during the application and removal process, which can be beneficial for people with weaker nails.

What nail service is least damaging? ›

Overall, Dip Powder Manicures are a great way to get a healthy manicure that will protect and strengthen your nails without causing any damage. Just like any nail treatment, you do have to make sure you properly remove it to keep your nails safe and healthy – Don't pick at your manicure!

What is the new alternative to gel nails? ›

For starters, BIAB is a professional-only soak-off soft-gel “specifically formulated to be used as an overlay on the natural nail,” explains Giorgia. It's gentler than acrylic, but thicker than regular nail polish and gel polish.

What type of nails look the most natural? ›

Squoval. "To get this shape, trim nails [with nail clippers] to the length you want in a square shape, and then use a nail file to round the corners," adds King. This shape is flattering on every finger type because it's the most natural, but it looks best on nails that are not longer than the fingertip.

Are gel nails more expensive than acrylic? ›

Gel is a thick, nail-polish type product, and while gel nails are strong, they're not thick. Acrylic nail application usually costs less than gel nail application.

What are the best nails for healthcare workers? ›

Short, well-manicured nails with or without polish is the best way to go. Your nails contain bacteria that they naturally pick up as you move through your day. The longer the nails, the harder it is to clean them.

What is a Russian manicure? ›

The Russian manicure technique removes as much skin as possible from the nail area, which leaves more room for polish. This results in a “cleaner”-looking finish and helps to extend the length of time between appointments, as the skin and nail take longer to grow back than with regular manicures.

What fake nails stay on the longest? ›

Best overall: Olive & June

They offer a whopping 41 nails in 21 sizes, the largest range on the market by a longshot. These nails are incredibly thick and durable, had no chipping, and stayed put for 18 days — the longest amount of time press-ons have ever lasted on me.

Do gel nails weaken natural nails? ›

The common misconception of a gel manicure is that it weakens and damages the nail, nail bed, and hardness of the nail. However, it has nothing to do with how often you do gel polish, but how it is removed. Typically, gel polish doesn't chip so much as peel from the nail after the initial first week.

Can gel nails be healthy? ›

Although gel manicures can be beautiful and long-lasting, they can be tough on nails. Gel manicures can cause nail brittleness, peeling and cracking, and repeated use can increase the risk for skin cancer and premature skin aging on the hands.

What is the healthiest alternative to acrylic nails? ›

Gel nail extensions are lighter and healthier for your natural nails. They are also safer because they do not use so many harsh chemicals. They are highly durable and long-lasting. They won't lift and fade quickly.

What is healthier than gel nails? ›

Watch out, gel and shellac, because there's a new, extremely durable manicure option that doesn't do as much damage to your healthy nails: BIAB nails. We've long loved manicures with gel or shellac because they have so many advantages over regular nail polish, but they have a few catches.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Frankie Dare

Last Updated:

Views: 6273

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (73 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Frankie Dare

Birthday: 2000-01-27

Address: Suite 313 45115 Caridad Freeway, Port Barabaraville, MS 66713

Phone: +3769542039359

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Baton twirling, Stand-up comedy, Leather crafting, Rugby, tabletop games, Jigsaw puzzles, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Frankie Dare, I am a funny, beautiful, proud, fair, pleasant, cheerful, enthusiastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.